Views : 745,005
Genre: Education
Date of upload: Jan 12, 2017 ^^
Rating : 4.804 (1,053/20,419 LTDR)
RYD date created : 2022-03-07T04:15:18.226735Z
See in json
Top Comments of this video!! :3
You certainly cover a problem but the "mind body problem" is a specific philosophical problem dealing with consciousness and the physical body: is the mind a physical thing? You should have chosen a different title for the video (not that you didn't cover an important topic but I was expecting something on the actual mind body problem).
749 |
I remember my favorite teacher in middle school was my 6th grade literature teacher. He was a skinny guy, & just goofy enough to keep us laughing. one day he heard someone say something mean to another student. Our teacher stopped everything and in the most serious tone told us a story about he himself , and how he was obese for many years. he explained the pain in great detail, the struggle of everyday. He than proceeded to say.
" obviously I lost all the weight and I'm healthy now. but every morning when I look in the mirror I will always see a huge, fat person. Doesn't matter if I weigh 200lbs or 70lbs. I'll always see that fat kid looking back at me." I'll never forget that story .
93 |
What's interesting is that for the first time in history we're about to enter an era where technology will allow us to customize what we look like (think cosmetic nanobots, effortless weight loss, skin/eye color choice, etc...) to an extremely high degree. This is already becoming true with designer babies and virtual reality. In fact, technology will start addressing some pretty fundamental physical and existential issues that have been around from the start.
But, when I hear "mind body problem" I tend to think it should refer to something deeper like 'how does an invisible mortal self-conscious "spirit" animate this flesh-meat body?', not something as superficial as "people don't look like they want to".
159 |
I got about 1 min into the vid and felt like what they were saying was wrong. Then with a quick google search confirmed that the mind body problem, in philosophy, refers to something very different....
I like school of life... but I would think that they would at least address this and say that they are dealing with totally different material than the original philosophical idea.
I mean both ideas might be the mind body problem, but they should clarify at the very least.
Also, not to be rude, but this is a much more basic idea than the more complicated one I found first search result on Google.
40 |
I think this problem is complicated by the fact that we are naturally attracted by physical attributes, as well as someone's mind. While it's nice to pretend that the two can be distinct and separate, I think it's probably more accurate to say that mind and body influence each other in profound ways. How we feel affects how we perceive. Our thoughts also influence how we feel. So while it's true that "who we are" is not "what we look like", separating the two is not straightforward. There is a bi-directional influence going on, and that should not be ignored. But perhaps we can become more aware of the influences on our thinking, and perhaps become more rational. For example, we might decide to realise the (potential) weaknesses of physical attraction and look beyond it for something deeper. We might filter our first impressions of someone and instead look behind the actions to see what motivates them, and try to learn more about the "real person" inside them. Then there's the challenge of doing that without coming across as creepy haha. Ah human interaction is so complicated.
9 |
@jerklecirque138
7 years ago
I think "mind-body problem" more typically refers to the mechanism by which the mind and body interact.
104 |