Views : 3,181,769
Genre: Education
Date of upload: Nov 6, 2021 ^^
Rating : 4.961 (1,146/115,851 LTDR)
RYD date created : 2022-04-09T21:23:01.817538Z
See in json
Top Comments of this video!! :3
I think a big part of what makes Goya's Saturn so unsettling for me is the utter inelegance in the way the mans body has been devoured. While Rubens' Saturn is obviously still horrific it still maintains an artful elegance to it, while the figure in Goya's has just been crudely devoured as it hangs limp, like a piece of meat. It's like coming upon the body of someone who has been partially eaten by a wild animal, slumped over in a ditch.
711 |
as someone with significant hearing loss, the two old men painting might be depicting the personification of tinnitus as a demon, in my experience tinnitus can very easily contribute to anxiety and depression, with feelings of hopelessness and fear. emotions that someone who is religious could view as a demon influencing and tormenting them.
1.1K |
Love how many of these paintings are so dark but dont use shock value, they use psychological deep fear. The fear of the unknown, of mortality, insanity, loneliness, and violence. He was committing suicide in his mind, but his body could do nothing but paint what he saw. Perhaps as a religious man, he embraced these truths instead of fleeing from them into the arms of self harm or suicide. He had to get the emotions out of himself and out into the world. The fact he painted these on the walls of his home is very telling. The home is often though of as an extension of the self. These paintings were private, almost like visual journals. The permanent nature of painting in his walls tells me that he knew he wasnât going to have a lot of time. So these would be forever put in place, unable to be separated from the artist, even after his death. He was saying âlook at me! But i am afraidâ
3K |
the most terrifying thing about these paintings is that the names given to each one of them are just what the people who first found them at Goya's house thought they meant. Goya never wrote any names or notes on them so "Cronos devouring his children" could perfectly represent something else.
Also this particular painting was on his dining room's wall so...
882 |
In the first painting, "The Dog", i'm almost quite convinced that the darker shading to the right of the dog looks like the silhouette of a man. I could be completely wrong but the way it's painted with sharper and more direct lines makes it look like a distinct shadow instead of a discoloration of the sky. Not sure! Would like to hear someone else's opinion on this. Fascinating paintings.
1.7K |
The missing head and arm of the figure being eaten in Saturn Devouring his Son was always really interesting to me. It makes me wonder if Goya painted Saturn as madness itself, and the figure being eaten represented Goya/Goyas life. Madness had already taken his mind (head) and his work (arm) and it was going to devour the rest of his life too.
98 |
A lot of people focus on the disturbing nature of "Saturn Devouring His Son," but something about "Man Mocked by Two Women" has always been extremely distressing to me. I think it's the total lack of context combined with the emotions suggested by the faces--we have little to no idea what's actually going on, but whatever it is, it is not pleasant or happy. It's an obscure-yet-all-too-clear vision of a really twisted side of human nature, one that takes pleasure in mocking or exploiting others. If, indeed, the man is mentally disabled, that adds an even darker context, as "care" for people with severe developmental issues at the time consisted of almost endless abuse and neglect, and there was virtually no understanding of mental illness.
2.3K |
You have to also realize how revolutionary they were in terms of the technique of painting. Goyaâs very loose and expressive brush work (probably because he never intended them to be shown) paved the way for a century of art movements after him. Hence why they regard him as the first âmodernâ painter.
Also you can see Goya using his knowledge of print making here, very stark contrasts of tones and simple, suggestive facial features, but in painting.
2.4K |
One idea that I find particularly insidious is about the Painting: Judith and Holofernes. The idea that the reason Holofernes isn't present in the painting is because Goya viewed himself as Holofernes. His mortality becoming more and more evident. Afraid of death and betrayal.
I could only imagine the dread of painting such a thing. A figure preparing to commit a brutal murder. With only one feasible target, you.
306 |
A little trivia: one of Goyaâs last works was a humorous caricature of himself as a decrepit old man with the label âaĂșn aprendoâ, which basically means âI still learnâ. After all the man had a brilliant sense of humor.
Pd: For anyone interested in Goyaâs body of work, I encourage you to look for his series of engravings, specially âThe Disasters of Warâ and âLos caprichosâ.
48 |
I have seen many of these "Black Paintings" out of context. Never knew they were painted on his wallpaper. That is pretty cool that someone meticulously removed them from the wall so the whole world can see them for generations. Very interesting video as always. I am excited to see what else you bring to us.
8K |
my psychiatrist recommended you to me recently and i can say im not at all disappointed. the spiraling mental decline of goya shown in his art is very reminiscent of schizophrenic patients art over time. especially surrounding himself with his art literally by drawing on the walls and his surroundings is another major red flag indicator of possible schizophrenia or psychosis. his art while beautiful tells a very tragic story of a man being consumed by his mind, may he rest in peace.
74 |
@WhenYoureAlexa
2 years ago
The fact he changed many paintings so dramatically has always made me think the initial paintings were much more optimistic, but being isolated and bitter he began changing them to match his developing anger and resentment.
7.5K |