ImmersiveAmbientModecolor: #d59885 (color 1)
Video Format : 22 (720p) openh264 ( https://github.com/cisco/openh264) mp4a.40.2 | 44100Hz
Audio Format: Opus - Normalized audio
PokeTubeEncryptID: 4989b3da58df5b713a3489a6ad7c2e09cf94452e148e14b6a96494ff26eab1ff229f6a33d140d5752c5a734860da0b5a
Proxy : eu-proxy.poketube.fun - refresh the page to change the proxy location
Date : 1714846806841 - unknown on Apple WebKit
Mystery text : MGNuS0Y1dXZnSlEgaSAgbG92ICB1IGV1LXByb3h5LnBva2V0dWJlLmZ1bg==
143 : true
17,841 Views • Jun 8, 2023 • Click to toggle off description
★- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ★
Want More THIS GUY EDITS?
☆Connect With Me:☆
➜ MY FREE WEBINAR-
filmindustrysecrets.com/
➜ ONLINE EDITING COURSE-
thegotoeditor.com/
➜ PATREON MEMBERSHIP-
www.patreon.com/thisguyedits
➜ INSTAGRAM-
instagram.com/thisguyedits
➜ TWITTER-
twitter.com/thisguyedits
➜ FACEBOOK GROUP-
www.facebook.com/groups/thisguyedis
➜ MY EDITING SETUP-
kit.co/thisguyedits
★- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ★
Music by Epidemic Sound - Get one month free here: thisguyedits.com/epidemic
#thisguyedits.com/5dd
All Rights Reserved
© Copyright 2023 This Guy Edits™
Views : 17,841
Genre: Film & Animation
Date of upload: Jun 8, 2023 ^^
Rating : 4.478 (94/626 LTDR)
RYD date created : 2024-04-04T01:51:28.591941Z
See in json
YouTube Comments - 138 Comments
Top Comments of this video!! :3
I can't believe I live in a time where artistic things are being industrialized
75 |
I think that's about right. I also don't think this is going to be nothing more than "helpful tools". The goal is to replace as many people as possible to maximize profits and minimize expense. They will come up with something for prompt based editing just like everything else computerized is becoming. This is also hitting me as a musician who writes commercial music for media and my regular job as an analyst. I'm running out of options!
The problem is that techies and business people don't understand creatives. They only look at the tech and how to find ways to automate and earn profits with no concern over human creativity. We enjoy experimentation and manipulation. We don't want to just type a prompt and have the computer do everything. We want to be "physical" and take pride in what we were able to accomplish, not what a computer can accomplish.
At some point, I think Ai will be able to analyze successful films, learn the edits that work for the type of film and emotional cues that have worked in the past and eventually have the ability to innovate. So, I'm not optimistic. The sad thing is that this is totally unnecessary for any purpose other than making profits. It won't help mankind, stop climate change, solve medical mysteries, create world peace, etc. We never needed AI for creative endeavors for any reason other than to help with menial tasks that allow us to work faster. Replacing us only helps a production company's bottom line.
19 |
It's probably going to become more competitive in the future because I have a strong feeling that AI will soon erase the need for assistant editors which will make it harder to get into the business. It's scary, I think, because even without AI many movies become formulaic due to the creative process being standardized and faster-paced and even with an editor and a director present to oversee it, there is a risk that a movie misses potential when it's not thoroughly viewed through a human's eyes. But it's interesting to see where it will go!
49 |
I recently tried out Autopod, the podcast editing AI plugin, that's been making rounds on all socials. It's good for when multiple people are talking over each other as it makes cuts whenever an audio track is active, but it doesn't cut out the "ums" or silence that I was hoping it would do. I'm sure AI video editing can give us very rough passes, but it's not gonna to replace quality anytime soon, I hope. 🤞
18 |
Loved you at the panel, sorry to hear you got it too! I just finished recovering.
This topic is one that is really terrifying to me, because I feel like it eliminated so many lower level opportunities for people to build up towards sitting in the chair. A lot of rungs on the ladder are going away.
2 |
finally someone who is actually scared of AI in this field! lol. honestly. all i read is people saying "all tech in human history ended up hiring more than firing" and "when new tech appears, people are always scared". nope. this is something else. and its gonna affect all industries, in all sectors.
if you can, please make a video about this software you were invited to test that you mentioned. im curious.
12 |
I feel it really depends on what kind of project you do. Of course just easy multicam talk editing can be automated. But cutting an interview of 30 min into 5 min? An AI would need to know what is important and the purpose.
It can also only do stuff that has been done before
17 |
Really appreciate your honesty and insights into the potential impact of AI on the editing industry. Your heartfelt honesty in sharing your fears struck a chord with me. It's a brave new world out there and your vulnerability in acknowledging the potential challenges and uncertainties is both frightening and inspiring. Your words have made me realize that we are all in this together, facing the unknown, but still holding on to our passion for storytelling. Please continue to share your journey with us. It's through such real, heartfelt conversations that we find the courage to navigate these changes. Your courage lights the way for all of us.
|
i started with film editing on beta tapes, moved on to music videos on computers, move on to zerodeadline news editing on betas, moved from there to super-fast news editing on computer again, retired due to illness. now i occasionally edit music videos, being free to choose projects, completely stress-free and loving it more than ever. AI will eventually "create" a flood of generic, ergo boring video content. a good editor knows the rules and knows how and when to break them. AI will learn the rules and stick to it...
3 |
Sorry l, my man - no way is AI going to replace 80% of editors in my opinion for the reason you stated in the video. AI won't understand pace. It will look at a gazillion examples and emulate them, but it wont understand them. If it cuts out all my selects and organises my shots then i say hell yes to that but as for building anything close to finish, i dont think so.
30 |
I used Adobe Premiere Pro with the AI transcript editing mode. It was extremely helpful to have the client remove unwanted content from a printed transcript and made the workflow smoother. I still had to go in and refine the rough cut and make it what we wanted. But how long before the machine can do it too?
4 |
Human error will be a hot commodity. Until AI replicates it with a superior error.
7 |
I think at some point AI will be able to anticipate audience reactions based on data from past successful movies, as well as the social and emotional climate of the world at the time it is building the cut.
14 |
Good overview!
Are you in IATSE? I'm in the process of joining and I believe organizing other freelance editors is going to be essential if we want any stability long term.
Because I think you're right that as soon as "good enough" is possible for corporate edits, etc most editors will be on the chopping block. But the WGA's demands for AI to not replace existing jobs is a good precedent for struggle with IP owners over AI.
|
It seems to me that the affect AI will have is editors will be more like an overseer that directs AI programs in how they go about a project, the purpose and such, it will be a much easier job and will probably pay way less I would guess, very unfortunate. I'm glad I went into a labor field remodeling houses because I think that sort of work will be the last to get hit because it will take advanced and inexpensive robotics to replace us, I'm sure it will happen in my lifetime though.
2 |
Hi Sven and thank you for sharing! As a film editor myself, I think a lot of the mainstream entertainment editorial workforce (think about reality shows as an example) could and/or will be axed down by A.I. For the cinema/tv-shows side of things I think it will be either something entirely made in AI (you push a button and it spits out a finished movie in a week) or not. I don't think the directors I work with (or most of the directors) will be willing to take all the sweat and blood they put in filming and painstakingly crafting the puzzle and just shove it into the mouth of the machine. Just my 2cents :)
|
As an editor who works on unscripted TV shows all day every day, I can't really see how AI is going to replace editors. How can you trust the AI to make all the tiny decisions and all the big decisions when the precise format, pacing and storyline aren't all perfectly laid out? I make literally thousands of small decisions every day. I need to communicate to producers constantly. I think AI will bring huge productivity gains and will eliminate the need for a lot of AEs and graphics people, but for video editors working on complex projects, I just don't see it happening anytime soon.
1 |
I would love to use AI to take over some of the pre-processing (sorting, tagging, setting possible cut markers, etc.). The creative side should always remain human for anything to be considered art - in my opinion.
|
An AI can do the initial assembly based on the script and “learning” as AIs start to digest film and video libraries. But it’s definitely going to take time before it can understand the nuances required in telling stories, and then it will only be mimicking and extrapolating editing styles and decisions. That being said, I don’t know if 80% is accurate, but it is going to be a significant percentage, and that’s goin to hurt.
1 |
@ThisGuyEdits
10 months ago
Check out my free editing mini-course: secreteditinghacks.com/
4 |