High Definition Standard Definition Theater
Video id : y3TnMMFTVHA
ImmersiveAmbientModecolor: #d2a498 (color 2)
Video Format : 22 (720p) openh264 ( https://github.com/cisco/openh264) mp4a.40.2 | 44100Hz
Audio Format: Opus - Normalized audio
PokeTubeEncryptID: a09559e5d4aa806afe2cc2dcc32aae5609fedeccbeea9dee8e85700b8ad34a636679ac2777d3294da5a202dcebfe6825
Proxy : eu-proxy.poketube.fun - refresh the page to change the proxy location
Date : 1716379726658 - unknown on Apple WebKit
Mystery text : eTNUbk1NRlRWSEEgaSAgbG92ICB1IGV1LXByb3h5LnBva2V0dWJlLmZ1bg==
143 : true
Rule of Rose: The Survival Horror that Lost to Plagiarism
Jump to Connections
788,341 Views ā€¢ Jun 17, 2023 ā€¢ Click to toggle off description
Rule of Rose is a game with a reputation that precedes it. After unfair slander in the media, the game caused a moral panic across Europe, even going so far as being discussed in the European Parliament - all for content that isn't even in the game. Today, I'd like to talk about this survival horror masterpiece and the controversy that erupted because of it.

Thank you to Y-Project from the Rule of Rose fan discord for creating the render of Clara used in the video. Join the Rule of Rose fan discord here: discord.gg/rrVd5Mwb42

SOCIAL MEDIA:
Twitch: www.twitch.tv/tangomushi
Twitter: twitter.com/iloveklim

CHAPTERS:
00:00 - Intro
2:41 - Gameplay
9:54 - Music
11:24 - Combat
17:03 - Plot analysis (SPOILERS)
36:00 - Plagiarism controversy
49:17 - Outro

MUSIC:
Library Menu - Yu-Gi-Oh! Forbidden Memories
Playing Airship - Rule of Rose
Backbiting - Rule of Rose
Jealous - Rule of Rose
Piano Etude I - Rule of Rose
Aristocrat Club - Rule of Rose
The Attic - Rule of Rose
1000 Year Slumber of the Bastia - Tales of Vesperia
Bullying - Rule of Rose
Metadata And Engagement

Views : 788,341
Genre: Gaming
Date of upload: Jun 17, 2023 ^^


Rating : 4.924 (738/37,931 LTDR)
RYD date created : 2024-05-22T09:51:50.746916Z
See in json
Tags

YouTube Comments - 1,904 Comments

Top Comments of this video!! :3

@MegaCygnusX1

11 months ago

Resident Evil - literally exploding zombies with magnums, shotguns, and rocket launchers - "...eh, this is fine." Rule of Rose - dark feminine socio-psychological horror with zero gore - "BAN THIS SICK FILTH."

3.1K |

@dxcSOUL

11 months ago

what's interesting is that an actual Lord of the Flies equivalent happened irl, where a bunch of boys had to survive on an island by themselves. Turns out, reality is far less cynical than we think sometimes. The boys worked together to survive and were rescued.

5.3K |

@guilhermehank4938

10 months ago

To these people that think children cant be vile, I just want to ask, "Have you ever met a child? Hell, have you ever BEEN a child?" Anyone that went through awful times as a child because of other children knows that they can be vile and manipulative so my only explanation is that the people who cant handle these negative portrayals of childhood probably dont want to accept they were the bullies themselves and feel guilty about it

1.3K |

@cogitae

10 months ago

A little detail about Clara's grooming that is even more terrible: something that caught my eye when I played the game is that the mermaid princess has stitches on her belly, stretch marks on her navel, tied legs by force and keeps vomiting nonstop. My guess is that Clara was pregnant with the old creep's baby and was either forced to get an abortion ( most likely done by him which explains why we barely see her ingame), or maybe he took her away to hide the pregnancy (and then joined her), or maybe even killed her elsewhere to hide his crimes (the main reason why he gets more twitchy as the game progresses) which is why we only see her boss fight and then never again. We will never know what happened to her or her unborn child. Also, Jennifer admits that she was always lazy as a kid and would let others do her chores, and Clara throughout the game seems to be the one who is the kindest and most attentive with Jennifer despite not seeing her actively, so it makes me think that Clara was the person who would do a lot of Jennifer's chores even while she was pregnant. Jennifer seeing through the keyholes as a kid would not only witness the r*pe and abuse without understanding what was going on, but then would also see her bedridden and vomiting (morning sickness) and as an adult she not only feels guilt over being a bystander to the whole situation, but also for having a pregnant kid doing her work while feeling very sick and heavy. And because Clara was gone and she never paid any mind to her dissapearence, it still haunts her how weak and selfish she was, even though it was none of her fault what happened to her.

2.5K |

@ab-gail

11 months ago

Those unused voice lines were amazing. The VA did a fantastic job. I felt her sorrow and fear there.

4.2K |

@jimmyjazz600

9 months ago

Hi, italian here. Just wanted to say that it doesn't surprise me one bit how the italian media created the moral panica around the videogame. I mean, the ignorance regarding the subject, the scaremongering reaching the parliament, the "won't somebody please think of the children" vibe, it all happens time and again in this country. Nothing has really evolved, if anything it got worse with social media. Also Panorama is just the lowest of conservative tabloids. Its reputation can't be buried, it never existed in the first place.

1.3K |

@metagasm820

11 months ago

So I'm a parent and someone who experienced trauma as a child. And I find it tragically funny that society can't handle depictions of children being evil/manipulative, when it's painfully common that children who come forward to authority figures about abuse that they've suffered at the hands of adults or other deep problems that they need support to navigate is dismissed as lying for attention or some other such manipulation. These are just some examples of how adults regard children with distrust when much of the time they're trying to express their needs and figure out how to be human beings. I feel like these two problems are related. Children are products of the adults around them, but only when it's convenient for the adults. Otherwise the adults shrug their shoulders and are like, "i dOn'T KnoW wHeRe hE/sHe gETs thAT fRoM???" They want to think that everything that's "wrong" with children just comes out of nowhere, (unless of course it presents an opportunity to blame/judge that child's family without actually offering support) and that bad things that happen to them serve the purpose of "teaching them a lesson." Children need guidance and support. They NEED it. They need someone in who truly has their best interests at heart, in terms both of unconditional love and accountability, to grow up functional and healthy. And yes all people, including children, are capable of bad things and even outright evil. But denying them their basic needs and rights as human beings for the sake of convenience (or worse, subjugation) is just cultivating that potential to its full fruition. We see this in Rule of Rose: these girls are left entirely to their own devices in this orphanage with no guidance from people who actually care about them and worse, people that abuse them. I feel like that's the entire point, as it is with Lord of the Flies. They see the pecking order that parents and authority figures model in front of them and internalize it. Then they're given free reign to do whatever they please with the morals and social understandings that have been demonstrated to them. That makes it rewarding to be the horrible person that you might already have a disposition toward in the first place. For children it's an uphill battle to be a good person because parents and authority figures can't be bothered to do their goddamn jobs. And those that actually care have more often than not been denied adequate support and resources to improve the situation and foster a healthy environment for their charges. The way this entire controversy around the game has been handled is further evidence of this. Authority figures failed to do their due diligence in no small part because of their derisive and objectifying attitude toward children. Especially in the case of Lord of the Flies, they hated having a mirror held up to their face. And this will continue to happen because people in power generally refuse to hold themselves accountable. It requires them admitting that they messed up and could potentially result in them losing the precious power that they value over literally everything else.

2.6K |

@terracottagecheese2767

10 months ago

I always appreciate a story that isn't afraid to depict children as acting cruel or perhaps even evil. Children often do awful things to each other without even really thinking about how their words and actions will affect someone in the long run. That and there are also instances of children doing unspeakable things and actually understanding how horrible their actions are, but simply not caring. It seems like adulthood tends to make a lot of people forget that, though childhood innocence can make one pure and good, it can also allow for incredibly horrible behavior with no care or thought given to the consequences of ones actions.

889 |

@nootnewt9323

11 months ago

The girls at the orphanage always wanted to play airship, thatā€™s why she sees it as an airship. She says she hated airship because thatā€™s where she lost her parents but sheā€™s also the only one who has been in one, so thatā€™s why sheā€™s able to imagine it so vividly when they forced her to play.

998 |

@adeadarcadia

11 months ago

The mermaid boss' model has surgical scars on her stomach indicating pregnancy, and "gills" on her wrist mean she could've committed suicide. There's also a cabinet in the room with Clara that, when the player tries to open, Clara immediately shuts. I'm skeptical that Hoffman killed her since she was seemingly alive when he bailed on them (as per his note), and if he would kill her to keep her silent, he probably would've killed Diana as well.

915 |

@reid3031

11 months ago

When you said "plagiarism", I thought people were going to be offended that it's a dainty lady named Jennifer in a psychological horror game with a dog, like Clock Tower and Haunting Ground combined into one game. I was unprepared for the truth.

743 |

@apizzathatgiantforthesimpl5191

11 months ago

In a weird way, I think the combat kind of fits? Jennifer is so beaten down by her circumstances and how she was treated. So any time she tries to fight back, even if she manages to do everything right, it still just comes off as unsatisfying, like she barely made a dent. At first you try to avoid your enemies, but then they start swarming you en masse. It's just so brutal and stupid and...unfair. A lot like the bullying itself, the fights just made me feel so helpless and angry, especially at Jennifer. I wanted Jennifer to stand up, to beat these little monsters senseless. So I feel like, from a metaphorical and story perspective, the combat works.

644 |

@makeitthrough_

11 months ago

"The only thing that's been buried alive is Panorama's professional integrity." God damn, that deserves the Overkill popup from FFX

671 |

@ScoundrelChestnut

11 months ago

the build up of "stray dog" and Gregory's showing up naked crouching like a dog made my heart plummet into my a** one of my absolute favorite horror sequences

735 |

@mrana4186

10 months ago

i'm not gonna lie, i literally cried when Brown died and when that flashback with him as a puppy happened, i knew he wouldn't be safe, it would have been foolish of me to think nothing will happen to him but it still hit me like a truck, the other things also have hit me in this game but horrible things happening to dogs always hits me the hardest

545 |

@awetistic5295

10 months ago

I went to a regular public school and it was just the same. My worst bully was a boy and it was very much the psychological route. In my experience, it's a myth that all boys are more straightforward and resolve conflicts with fists. Maybe in kindergarten or early elementary school, but later on, everyone's equally bad. We had the hierarchy, the bullying, the schemes. Even some teachers gladly joined in. I still have nightmares about school several times a week and I'm 37 now.

402 |

@SanguinaryBlade

11 months ago

Adding to Clara's design as a boss, I recall a video some time ago drawing my attention to that her legs are tightly bound together, she's confined but also its a self destructive effort to keep her legs closed, to protect and destroy/remove a part of herself that brings her so much disgust. She also throws up everywhere in the fight, eating disorders being a very common response to trauma, especially for young girls of around her age. On top of this the visualisation of Clara as a mermaid, a mythical creature, seems quite in line with dissociating and going away into a fantasy in the mind. I don't recall in the game how much Jennifer sees, or how much is confirmed about how Clara reacts to all her trauma, but thats kind of the beauty of her design. How much is a reflection of what happened? Did Jennifer notice Clara throwing up several times? Did she see Clara having difficulty walking, or trying to keep her legs together a lot? There's so many possibilities and we don't necessarily know for sure, but its enough implied that the reaction is visceral and so very uncomfortable. Its one of those things where the truest horrors are left implied.

2.2K |

@jaeon0095

11 months ago

I went to an all-boys school, and believe me, it is the same. The social heirarchy, the bullying... It made me resent people for a very long time, but I'm glad I was able to put it all behind me. Great video again btw! I'm always looking forward for your next one!

3K |

@usmansubhani7482

10 months ago

As a kid I was also that one fat girl in this story. The one being bullied and taking joy when a ā€˜pushoverā€™ came to my class who ironically had the same name as me. In the end, what I did only made me more isolatedā€¦ Me bullying that person only became a regret for me. I should have beenā€¦ nicer.

214 |

@Lord_Jackalope

10 months ago

So many bullies go on wanting to completely forget or suppress the literally horrific things that they did to people and I speak this from a personal experience that they assume that anything that they did was never as bad as people make it out to seem because they want to cope with the fact that they completely and brutally hurt someone without remorse so much so that they go on to believe no child could ever do or be ā€œevilā€ but anyway this was a fantastic video thank you for making it.

51 |

Go To Top