Views : 6,439
Genre: Music
Date of upload: Oct 25, 2023 ^^
Rating : 4.963 (2/212 LTDR)
RYD date created : 2024-05-04T12:27:02.666224Z
See in json
Top Comments of this video!! :3
Itās interesting. His approach to piano is how Iāve approached ukulele and guitar my whole life - legitimately only looking at chord and tab charts to play the music, never knowing what actual notes make up a chord or WHY they make up that chord. Iāve really only recently realized how sucky this approach has been at the age of 31. Iām learning to play piano for the first time and starting at the bottom, learning how to read music. Iām not going to lie, itās hard for me. But, it is vital. C Major scales with both hands? My god, how tricky is THAT? I really think leaving things like that out and expecting that someone could play moving chords with the right hand while āspammingā keys on the left hand is kind of extreme. Although grueling, I know that being able to do a C major scale with both hands will allow me to really connect both my hands and it will eventually click. Getting that down will set me up to really get other movements down.
Honestly, I got really excited the first time I was able to do the C Major scale in each hand separately for the first time. There is still joy in learning the fundamentals. Then again, Iām only on day 4 or so, so Iām sure that will change. š
On the other hand, I do think itās fun to every now and then learn something random. I did learn how to play the intro to a song with relatively basic chords. I still do not remember the names of those chords, the notes Iām hitting while playing, and why it all works. Itās interesting because I do know the notes, I just have to stare at the keys before Iām certain.
I just think learning this new instrument is breathing new life into me and even learning how to read music is fun for now. I think itās really going to open up my guitar and ukulele skills as well.
6 |
Oh my...It seems you're really upset about this videoš¤£. And I have to say that you're absolutely right!!!
Why? Now, I'm a self learner since 3 years. I practice on the average an hour a day. And I think I can play "Perfect" in any key also with arpeggios etc. BUT as you say there's a lot of MUSIC THEORY knowledge behind that I built up through time. Without that, even if I were able to play like he claims one could (via spamming, going ham on the notes etc etc - and I have absolutely no clue what he means because I don't think he does either!), it would be nothing more than just copying what he's doing, sort of like in a computer game. And when someone gives me the chord chart of a second song to play, I would be lost!!!
So you have every right to be upset; I would actually be very angry in your place! I'm actually kind of angry with my only 3 years of learning / playing experience AND knowledge of MUSIC THEORY!
10 |
@CarMoves
1 month ago
To be fair, Ali's approach is just to get someone playing "something/anything" that they know, so they catch the "piano bug". At this point, the goal is to "keep interest" not "teach". Then when the student is addicted and motivated then you can bring in the "why", the counting, the inversions, etc. That's why on guitar you learn AC/DC, that first easy riff is addictive
3 |