Views : 905,800
Genre: Entertainment
Date of upload: Sep 13, 2022 ^^
Rating : 4.961 (335/34,324 LTDR)
RYD date created : 2024-05-22T11:34:21.78266Z
See in json
Top Comments of this video!! :3
The lack of culture among the Trisolarans highlights an interesting idea that Liu touched on, but then abandoned: the idea that the stagnation and death of art can be an existential threat. We see the Trisolarans become obsessed with Earth culture in both the second and third books. This could potentially been used as a weapon by Earth to destabilize Trisolaran society or force a symbiotic relationship, even though it ultimately wasn't.
1.8K |
SPOILERS - I think it was a very important part of the original trilogy that earth never saw the Trisolarans. It gave them an even greater psychological advantage because an imagined threat can be far more intimidating than a known threat. It also allows the reader to constantly change their perception of them as the story continues. And, it makes scenes like the living computer even more crazy to imagine when you think about human size creatures trying such an endeavor.
The revelation of them being insect like, canon or not, was great because when you look back and apply it to their decision making process it produces a lot of AHAH moments. Like how they were willing to force humans to survive by cannibalizing each other. I think humans would be more reluctant to use a tactic like that, even on an alien race, because it is a barbaric concept to us. But for them, they put little value on the individual life, so they have no issue forcing that mentality on another race.
1.1K |
One of the things that Trisolaran mass cognition implies is that Listener was not a lone dissatisfied actor. If Trisolarans are truely incapable of individual thought to such an extreme degree, then the Listener must represent an aspect of Trisolaran group thought... an undercurrent that constantly runs counter to the mass desire. And there is good evolutionary reasoning for this. A truely singleminded group consciousness would be inflexible to change and not adaptable, and adaptability is the most important trait for a species on a planet in a three-body system. So the species has to have a mechanism to cultivate undercurrents of subversive thought, even while the totalitarian impulse remains the dominant force. So the Listener is then perhaps a focal point for a collective subversion, which is why he desires things like love and art that he cannot possibly really have personal references for. Its why he feels this strong empathy towards Earth culture, because of the subversive leanings of other individuals. He is then the Listener not just Earth signals, but of those kinds of thoughts within the collective. This also explains the need for extreme martial law. Deviants are then not lone bad actors in Trisolaran society, but focal points for mass anti-social thought. Which makes them far more dangerous to the totalitarian body than a lone actor. But it also explains how they were suddenly able to lie when we are told explicitly they are incapable of lies... the main body of totalitarian thought maintains the party line that all thought is known and contained, while the undetected undercurrents keep different forms of thought alive as resevoirs for survival. This in itself is subterfuge, lying is therefore part of the Trisolaran deep nature. Just one that they hide from themselves.
This all reflects back on Chinese history and the need to purge intellectuals and provacateurs who were far more dangerous to the revolution than individual dissidents would be. Im reading Ai Weiwei's book One Thousand Years of Joy and Sorrow and it is actually a really excellent companion piece to the The Body Problem books for someone from the West to understand some of the background of the revolution and how the Chinese political body became so hyper-focused on stamping out reactionary thought.
429 |
"They're bugs!"
This blew my mind. Quinn, I am so grateful for your work and exposing me to this book trilogy. All that I know of it is what you have progressively revealed, but I have learned of and been horrified by the Droplet, all the history of Earth in dealing with the menace and now to learn that they are tiny little beings the size of grains of rice, it feels wonderfully appropriately weird and just the kind of impossible that bears the mark of sincerity. I've been thinking on it all day. Thank you so much for the compelling ideas, I really value them! Godspeed, Quinn!
🌟
194 |
The size and intelligence of the Trisolarans, in Baoshu's sequel, sent chills through my spine as I read about them. I don't consider the rest of the sequel to be canon (because it's weird loll). But those small details about Trisolarans' biology was spot on! It just made so much sense!!! I felt as if I should have known all along, as if it was now so obvious!
Suddenly, the lack of individuality within their social structure seemed perfectly normal, without the actual cognitive ability for an individual to be something complex. Individuals have tiny minuscule brains, they are extremely simple creatures, barely sentient. Communication generates intelligence, complexity. Therefore, when an individual becomes weak, sick or dysfunctional, it's not immoral to destroy them, it's necessary. Like a broken cell in our body. Even the Trisolarans themselves don't even seem to care that much when they must be killed. Even having sex kills them loll.
What I would have liked to know are the demographics of the Trisolarans. There's a quadrillion ants on Earth (a million billions!)... So... Loll
234 |
I'd recommend the zones of thought series. It explores more the idea of a society where thoughts and intelligence is a shared thing requiring multiple individuals, but in another way. The dog-like Tines require a pack of 3 to 6 individuals in order to make a singular full self aware person. So they have a culture built on the science of creating and cultivating minds by mixing and matching individual bodies within a group. However the twist on the usual hive mind concept is that they're only able to function with an optimal number. Too many and they become dumber, until they become something too incoherent to be a single mind.
134 |
I've started reading the three body problem series based solely on you videos Quinn. You have greatly turned me on to books I never would have known of. I always thought of myself as a massive sci-fi fan but your videos have really opened my eyes to sci-fi stories that I was sorely missing in my reading.
13 |
@RSK412
1 year ago
The size of the Trisolarans reminds me of a quote by Douglas Adams, it goes: "...the mighty ships tore across the empty wastes of space and finally dived screaming on to the first planet they came across - which happened to be the Earth - where due to a terrible miscalculation of scale the entire battle fleet was accidentally swallowed by a small dog." 🤣
5.4K |