Views : 79,147
Genre: Travel & Events
Date of upload: Feb 5, 2021 ^^
Rating : 4.908 (58/2,454 LTDR)
RYD date created : 2022-01-19T12:03:06.577573Z
See in json
Top Comments of this video!! :3
Hi Simply Railway! As a Long Island native and railfan, I take great pride in the railroad that I classify as my favorite. With that being said, I would like to address a few things mentioned in the video. I will address them in the order mentioned. Firstly, the lack of outlets. While there are outlets on the C3s, there are very few. The reasoning behind this is that these cars were built and commissioned in the fall of '98, where mobile devices were far less common. Secondly, the feeling of being cramped. That is actually by design. The C3 was designed to provide more room for passengers at stations with smaller platforms. Because of those smaller platforms, they have to run smaller trains, but still wanted the capacity. This, we have the C3. And finally, I want to address the conductor. Knowing about her conduct is truly baffling to me, as everyone I have ever interacted with has been professional and courteous. I assure you that encounters like that are rare, though not unheard of. I also highly propose that you take one of the trains out to Montauk as the sights out there are truly stunning, and it will be well worth the fare. Thank you for reviewing the LIRR, and keep making this content.
71 |
The reason why the C3's are such a cramped bi-level coach is because of the tunnel clearances at New York Penn Station. The tunnel clearance is such that ordinary bi-levels (like the bombardier bi-level that you rode on TRE), cannot fit into Penn Station, and thus the C3's had to fit the clearance at Penn Station while still being high-capacity bi-levels.
135 |
I've had a couple of experiences of railway staff, although the other way around: One was at Antwerpen Centraal where a driver said he'd seen us previously and would love to see the photos we took (which went on Flickr at the time) and a German train driver who was interested in my taking pictures at Hamburg Hbf & was impressed with my knowledge of both German and how their rail system worked. And the Amtrak & Metra staff I encountered in Chicago were lovely; very chatty and curious as to why I was venturing into the suburbs and not staying downtown! Just a shame you got someone who wasn't like the staff I've met. Certainly a very interesting train in this video; thanks for sharing :D
41 |
Nice trip report! I'm sorry that you have to go through what the conductor did. Not everyone is a nice person in NY. You made a couple of minor mistakes with information: 1. Jamaica Station is in Queens, not Brooklyn, and 2. Taking the elevator is an option to get to the platforms but not the only option, as you can walk out of the ticketing office, walk underneath the tracks at street level and you can find your tracks from the various stairwells leading directly up to the platforms. But overall, great trip report!
57 |
As someone who was born and raised on LI and someone who travels on the LIRR frequently...man this did not put our best foot forward. I'm sorry you had a bad experience, especially with that conductor.
If you're ever in the area again, might I suggest a ride on the Montauk branch from Penn! Same loco and rolling stock but most of the line is elevated along the south shore in Nassau and you get some great views!
8 |
@damascus6478
3 years ago
Jamaica station is in the borough of Queens, not Brooklyn. The station is the Long Island Railroad"s major interchange between trains from Manhattan and Lon Island. "Change at Jamaica" is one of those phrases that every New Yorker is familiar with. It's almost like "Mind the Gap" in London. In fact, there was a restaurant in Glasgow called Change at Jamaica, sadly long since closed.
235 |