Views : 25,381
Genre: Education
Date of upload: Mar 9, 2020 ^^
Rating : 4.916 (28/1,309 LTDR)
RYD date created : 2022-01-19T20:18:38.491516Z
See in json
Top Comments of this video!! :3
Few years ago I never thought I could make an original song. I found this channel and it filled in so many gaps in my musical knowledge. It got me to start writing music and I haven’t stopped. Found that motivation and confidence. I attribute much of that to this channel. Jake is a good teacher.
47 |
I think one of the biggest myths - and this holds across disciplines, not just in music - is that because someone has mastered their art, or is famous or whatever, they will make the best teacher. That is wrong. Teaching is it's own discipline, and it requires the same level of dedication to master as any discipline.
I studied architecture as a young man, and had many teachers over the years. Some were world famous architects, and these tended to be the worst. Some were downright abusive. Years later I became a college professor myself, and it took me 5 or 6 years to truly master the art of teaching. Here is what I learned:
1) Teaching is fundamentally about communication. Each student has strengths and weaknesses. It's your job as an instructor to figure out what each student needs to grow as an artist and performer, and to provide a road-map and process for them to follow to realize their unique potential.
2) While criticism is an important part of developing skills, it's important that criticism be directed at the WORK not the PERSON. I can't stress this enough. It must also be balanced with encouragement and praise for work as it improves.
3) I saw my role as a teacher as that of an enabler. As a door opener, not as a gatekeeper. It's your job to impart a solid development process and work ethic to your students, so that they can continue to grow after studying with you.
4) We all have likes and dislikes when it comes to our art. Some of your students will have entirely different sensibilities, and you must respect these and encourage your students to follow their muse, not necessarily your own. This is one of the most difficult things to achieve, but it is essential.
5) It's not about YOU. You are being paid to help the STUDENT achieve their goals. They are not vessels for your own ambitions or whipping boys and girls for your own frustrations. Get over yourself, and leave your goddamed ego at the door.
While a certain level of mastery is required to be a good teacher, it's also true that the one eyed man is king in the land of the blind. You need not be a virtuoso player to teach good technique. You don't have to have an encyclopedic knowledge of theory to teach the circle of 5ths, the major scale, or basic chord construction, and the 80/20 rule always applies - the most essential 20% of theory and technique will give you 80% of the benefit so focus on that with beginning students - the basics are the foundation of everything.
I started seriously studying music 5 years ago. I'm in my 50s now, and have made stunning progress by following a few basic habits, rules, and techniques:
1) Find good teachers - online and IRL.
2) Commit to studying and practicing DAILY. Find an online teacher with a structured curriculum and PAY FOR IT. I started with Griff Hamilin's blues courses, but any well organized curriculum is a good place to start. I've spent at least one to two hours daily at guitar and theory since 2015, and I'm now playing with professional level people. I have one of the world's best hard-rock guitarists as a mentor now as a result. Seriously - one of the best. He sought me out as a student after seeing my chops in videos and reading my posts about WHY I play. For me music is a spiritual thing, not an ego thing. I'm fortunate that other musicians like my playing, but I'd play regardless. It's just something I have to do - it feeds my soul.
3) Record or film yourself playing from the start, and review and critique your playing regularly. Build on what's working well, and avoid doing what isn't, and you'll rapidly improve. Fail to do this, and all the practice in the world won't help.
4) You have to LOVE music and you have to love your instrument(s) or forget about it. The only way to get really good - no matter how gifted you are - is to put in thousands of hours developing your chops and knowledge and artistic vision. That's not gonna happen unless you love it.
Peace.
15 |
One more thing that IMHO is a sign of a bad music teacher is trying to create a little clone of yourself.
Of course starting with the things that you know worked for yourself is fine, but the ultimate goal of a music teacher is bringing out what's inside each individual student and try to make it blossom.
Providing guidance is one thing, forcing your vision on someone else is a sure way to erase the passion for music out of someone
9 |
I had a terrible guitar teacher on guitar at 15, made me not even want to play ever again. 15 years later I'm 30 and I really wanted to play because I really do love guitar so I go to a new music school 3 towns over and they paired me with that SAME GUY. He sits down and says "let's see what you can do" and lays down the bridge to stairway to heaven. I told him he was responsible for ruining music for a lot of people and I walked out. I did find someone great now I live for guitar and I play, study and think about music everyday.
2 |
Here's my (brief) story and why I think the circle of 5ths is helpful.
I started playing guitar all of 9 months ago and much later in life (40's). I got a teacher (who I rather like) about 5-6 months ago. This is my 4th attempt in my life to learn guitar, the other three being STUNNING failures that lead me to be convinced for most of my life I was solidly in the "just didn't have what it takes" camp. Some people can play and some can't and I can't. And I was incredibly wrong. What changed about 9 months ago is I stumbled across a website and learned the absolute basic of theory. What that's allowed me to do is understand the underlying 'math' that underpins music. About 6 months ago, I found the circle of fifths. It gave me a common 'cheat sheet' guide that allows me to quickly figure out something I'm stuck on. I love it! I'm not saying it makes me a better guitarist, just that it gives me a comfort tool that allows me to stretch myself because I know I can always fall back on the 'theory' bit encapsulated in the Circle if I find myself stuck and lost. I think of it like a road map I can follow even if I get off the path from time to time.
That's not to say this is the One True Path for everyone. Just another perspective on a different sort of student. I tried and failed with the more 'loose' approaches to teach where I would just learn to play things. It didn't work so well for me as I'd get frustrated not understanding why this followed that. Now, because of the Circle, I understand a G Major scale has 1 sharp (because it's at 1 o'clock') and that sharp is going to be F# because F is always the first sharp. And if someone asks me, "what are the sharps in A major?", because I've got a rough visualization of that stuff in my head from the circle, I know that is going to be 3 sharps, which means F, C, G. I helps me personally as a comfort blanket if nothing else.
Just another perspective is all...
12 |
Keep it up Jake! You're definitely one of the best teacher's I've had the pleasure of watching. I've learned so much from your Youtube videos and try to take a little bit of your teaching in every song that I write. Before I had your videos, I didn't know much about theory at all. So, thanks for everything and keep doing what you do!
5 |
A good teacher is one that inspires the student to learn and makes learning fun. A bad teacher is one who only cares about a syllabus and ticking off a check sheet so they can say they are doing their jobs. Overbearing and / or discouraging behaviour are sure signs of a bad teacher. That is not just in terms of music, but can be in any subject. My own schooling suffered because of a lot of teachers like this. Thankfully, these days, it seems that general teaching standards have risen a lot (at least here in the UK).
2 |
Jake, you are an amazing teacher! I never understood the modes until you, thank you! I have also learned a lot about composition and functional harmony from your channel. I dont even play the guitar, yet your channel is one of my go-to's for continuing education. As a follower of adult pedagogical methods, I can tell you that the only thing I learn from most "teachers" on youtube and other platforms is how good they are -- not how to achieve my learning goals. Thanks again for your channel and teachings!
14 |
You are an excellent teacher. I've heard a lot of basic musical concepts before and never really understood them until I found your channel. You make it interesting and easy to understand and give real examples of the concept at work in popular songs, or in your own works. Thats why I show a little love on your patreon.
1 |
Cool topic. At 13:35 Jake says it perfect: you want to teach the student to be a self teacher.
Bad teacher: teaches random tidbit each week, leaves you wandering in the wilds. Or they play a lot but teach little.
Good teacher: Teaches the basic framework so the student can then choose their own path deliberately.
6 |
@barttennekes544
4 years ago
Lol this guy is so good at teaching music theory, he even started teaching other to teach music theory. This channel deserves every one of those 343K subs it has.
84 |