Views : 302,920
Genre: Education
Date of upload: Feb 1, 2019 ^^
Rating : 4.955 (95/8,341 LTDR)
RYD date created : 2022-03-31T09:30:37.060884Z
See in json
Top Comments of this video!! :3
Saxophonist with absolute pitch here. I started on violin as a youngster and thus grew accustomed to concert pitch. When I started alto sax at age 11 I swore there was something wrong with my instrument because my Câs were coming out as Ebâs. Then someone explained transposition to me. Mild pain, but I eventually got used to it.
Then, in college as a freshman, I was asked to play tenor 2 in our schoolâs big band. It was my first time playing a Bb sax, and it BROKE MY BRAIN! (for a while at leastâŚ) At that point my mind had been accustomed to concert pitch in most theory/writing exercises, **and had hard-coded Eb transposition to saxophone fingerings**. Even though I consciously knew that t sax was a Bb instrument⌠when reading / fingering a C, my brain subconsciously expected an Eb, and when Bb came out instead, the cognitive dissonance was almost too much to handle. It took me a solid 3 weeks to get over it.
217 |
I was surprised that I needed to explain this to my piano teacher. Iâm a sax player so it comes naturally to me. But what I couldnât explain was why Bb seemed to have won out in history with so many instruments in that key. It seems like you could have made those instruments at bit smaller and you would be in C, saving a lot of confusion and not changing the range much.
223 |
There are some shortcuts you can take to make life easier. Reading an Eb part in treble clef is the same as reading concert pitch in bass clef, adding three sharps. Reading a Bb part in treble clef is the same as reading concert ptich in tenor clef, adding two sharps. Once you think of transposition as a game of "which clef am I reading this in?", it becomes way easier in my opinion. Especially if you're unfortunate enough to be afflicted with perfect pitch like I am.
38 |
1:34 Thank you for mentioning the unicorn trumpet, this one is always forgotten! đ
5 |
I have been a vocalist most of my life. The first time I became aware of transposing instruments is when I went back home for my class reunion. A former classmate, who was a composer, asked me to rehearse the instrumentalists while he ran an important errand. He gave me the sheet music to hand out to the musicians. That is when I noticed different key signatures on the score. It was quite a revelation!
22 |
Had great "fun" doing all the transpositions for brass instruments to cover them during a Christmas cantata presentation; our local ensemble had no brass players, so had to cover them as best can on an old but capable electronic organ. The organ had quite good PCM sound, so quite realistic simulation. Had to write in all the parts in Finale, then switched back to "concert pitch" to enable playback on the keyboard. But it was a great practical lesson on the array of transposing instruments.
1 |
@BradHarrison
7 months ago
Take private lessons online with me! Trumpet, brass, theory, composition & arranging, improvisation, or whatever musical/life coaching youâd like to work on. More information at www.bradharrison.ca/lessons
1 |