Views : 436,437
Genre: Education
Date of upload: Jun 30, 2023 ^^
Rating : 4.747 (917/13,553 LTDR)
RYD date created : 2024-05-13T03:48:18.98657Z
See in json
Top Comments of this video!! :3
I quite liked the demon episode, it felt very black mirror in mood. I could very easily buy it being tech related vs supernatural as well, being part of some quantum computer multiverse not unlike the Joan episode. then you can think of that the 'endless void' they were meant to go to could theoretically have a backdoor that they could have a callister style ending.
but the werewolf, I just feel like there needed to be a during credit montage expanding on the cover up/science/supernatural something and possibly some sort of hook or seed for werewolves (be they science based or supernatural) earlier in the episode. the episode felt very incomplete somehow.
522 |
I think part of the Loch Henry techno-horror aspect is that when we use technology to store our memories, we lose some degree of private ownership of our memories. While we think the lack of agency of technology like a videotape, or book, makes them good stewards of our memories, that they'll never knowingly share our secret, really that is their weakness. They can never knowingly keep your secret, it has no ability of choice and the secret becomes free for everyone that can access it
216 |
My legit response to Beyond the sea was âIâm tired of seeing Jessie Pinkman get fucked overâ as a type cast actor and a former character thatâs misfortunes was our entertainment, do you think that was a larger meta intent of the show creator for this episode? It would fit with in the larger critique.
43 |
I thought this season was more about obsession. Like, usually black mirror is about our obsession with technology, with the focus being technology, but I thought this was more about obsession. Joan was obsessed with having the perfect life. Loch Henry was about their obsession with getting the story. In Beyond the sea, the cult became obsessed with the replica and then Josh hartnett became obsessed with Aaron Paulâs wife, while Aaron Paul always wanted to be in control. The paparazzi were obsessed with getting the money shot. And in demon 79 she was obsessed with making her third victim the evil politician and the demon with completing the 3 kills. Joan eventually learned to let go of her obsession and got a happy ending. In demon 79, once the mission is over and they both move on, they get a happy ending. Meanwhile, Piaâs obsession cost her her life and the guy got his perfect story, but at what cost? And of course the astronauts are both miserable with no way to end it. So, just like most episodes are like a warning about what our obsession with technology could lead to, this was a warning about what happens if we let our obsession consume us.
181 |
I think black mirror isn't so much about media as it is about the dark side of human nature. Media just happens to be a great catalyst to enhance it. At least that's the way I felt with earlier seasons, with the episode "White Christmas" being my absolute favorite of the series. From the latest season, I feel like only the third and second episode manage to properly do this, and even then it was to limited effect compared to previous seasons.
It's not so much that the over-arching themes feel off, it's something about the execution that feels like it's lacking, and I can't exactly put my finger onto what exactly that thing is.
94 |
While Demon 79 is mostly about political media ( the rhetoric used by politicians/speeches/pamphlets etc.) It is also about media more broadly.
She is always watching TV alone in her apartment, she has no friends and no life outside of this. Even when she is meant to get murdering she insists on watching TV instead, getting angry when the Demon tries to remove her from the TV ("I was watching that") - even though she needs to prevent the apocalypse.
We also see her actively turn off the news which she finds hard to listen to as it depicts the awful things of the world. Despite having NF stuff graffitied on her door she would rather ignore it ( "I was going to paint over it") and hide from the (very real) issues that she is facing. She accepts the cruelty of her co-workers and allows herself to be pacified by the nicer things on the tv. The demon even appears to her as "The man from boney m" because that is what in her conscious mind she finds the most appealing and comforting. It is only once a demon literally shows her the horrid images of the world in her head that she faces the truth and stop allowing herself to be nullified and instead decides to take things into her own hands - addressing the racism and oppression head on. (Which includes new stories about politicians, nuclear war and even the guy who murdered his wife.)
It also hits different when you realise the personal connection, Brooker's wife Konnie Huq is an Asian woman and her parents likely came over in the era this episode is set in, her sister is also a Labour Party MP. So then you kind of begin to see this episode of also giving women of colour a space in supernatural story telling whilst also reflecting on the issues faced by people of this era in a new perspective ( The real demon was the Tory politician, and the actual demon from the nether realm was an alright guy) .
38 |
I didn't mind the serial killer documentary episode, which had a more subtle touch in regard to technology, the media, etc. The astronaut episode was also pretty good, though it would have made more sense to set it in the future rather than an alternative past. (Also, if I could nit-pick, wouldn't it be smarter/safer to send the artificial copies into space so the real people could stay on Earth?). The Streamberry episode was the best, and the most in line with the show's typical themes. But the final two episodes, the werewolf ep and the demon ep, made no sense to me in regard to the show's premise. Black Mirror has always been about the real world and the ways in which technology impacts our lives, but the show really jumped the shark here, going full-on supernatural in a way that just doesn't fit within the context of the show. They weren't terrible episodes of TV per se, but they just weren't Black Mirror.
169 |
I've not overly concerned myself with critics, just my own take. Oddly, I figure that as an adult I can make up my own mind. What I found most interesting is that in this season, it was closer to intent to its inspiration. Rod Serling had many axes to grind, but in his era, he simply could not say the things he wanted to say. I love the man's work, and until a couple of years ago I had a paperback that held four of his teleplays from live TV. This season felt, to me, like an homage to Serling, weaving in some fantasy (werewolf) and schlock horror to awesome effect. He isn't everyone's cuppa, and that's fine, so long as enough people watch it to make Streamberry a desire to make more.
53 |
@SkipIntroYT
10 months ago
To check out the full discussion with Jessie Gender, consider supporting the channel on Patreon: tinyurl.com/muse7etm
92 |