@ElMaestroModoFran

2 weeks ago

The reason because John didn't mention Arthur in RDR1 beyond the fact that they didn't plan it, it seems to me that this can also have a symbolic meaning. In certain conversations, such as with his family for example, in the Epilogue of RDR2, Jack and Abigail were talking about Arthur, where she herself says that John doesn't like to talk much about that, to which he himself affirms it. It is also said that John never forgets Arthur, he just does not mention him, because of everything he lived with him, he became ill, causing him to want to redeem himself and be a good person, to finally die saving his loved ones, including John. Another thing to add is that those who spoke about Arthur were mostly acquaintances, or rather, people who also knew Arthur, like Mary-Beth, the native whose name I don't remember, I think it was Aguila or something like that, her own family, Charles, Sadie, and finally with Micah along with Dutch, which to explain why they did not talk about him almost at the end of Red Dead Redemption 1, it could be explained that John was too focused on his mission to talk to him about Arthur, but that Dutch at that moment was probably thinking about him, since the things he says are similar to things he said in a certain mission, in which he was with Arthur: "We can't fight...gravity", that could also be part of what I'm saying. There are many more things but I am going on too long.

3 |